Andre Onana
Had little handling to do in the first half but his distribution was questionable at times. Not as erratic after half-time. 6
Diogo Dalot
Rinsed by Jeremy Doku in the first half. He had a calmer start to the second and moved across to left back when Harry Maguire went off. Converted his penalty. 6
Harry Maguire
Coped decently amid City’s spells of pressure and came through unscathed after missing the friendly with Liverpool last week. 6
Jonny Evans
Did not look as comfortable as he did as a starter against City earlier this year in the first 20 minutes but regained composure. Horrific penalty. 5
Lisandro Martinez
His first start at left back for United and he was let off the hook when James McAtee hit the post. Moved back to centre back after Maguire was substitued and intervened a couple of times. 6
Casemiro
More effective as an attacking, rather than defensive, midfielder as he fashioned chances for Amad and Marcus Rashford. 7
Kobbie Mainoo
Eased his way back into the team on his first United appearance since the FA Cup final. Clipped a nice pass to instigate an attack. 6
Amad
Ignored by teammates at times and when he finally got the ball he had United’s first chance. Should have scored with his second opportunity. 6
Mason Mount
A quiet start on his ninth United start but grew into the game. Failed to maintain that level into the second half and came off. 5
Marcus Rashford
Shanked a good chance not long before half-time and then fluffed an even better chance well into the second half. 5
Bruno Fernandes
As busy as ever and scored a great goal-that-never-was when he strayed offside before lobbing Ederson. Sparked the attack Rashford missed his chance from. Scored in the shootout. 8
Subs
Toby Collyer
Lively and eager on and off the ball. 7
Scott McTominay
Could and should have got onto Rashford’s header. Put his penalty away. 6
Alejandro Garnacho
Created a brilliant chance for Rashford and scored a brilliant goal. 8
Facundo Pellistri
A fish out of water at right back and got done by Bernardo Silva for the equaliser. 4
Jadon Sancho
Prepared to come on at 0-0 and United went 1-0 up when he did emerge. 5
Manager
Opted for a logical balance of touring and international players. Freshened United up at the right time and Garnacho should have been the matchwinner. 7