In 2011, Olivia Wilde paid almost $2.3 million for a bachelorette pad that had previously been owned by puppeteer, director, and producer Brian Henson, the son of renowned Muppets creator Jim Henson, and was allegedly rented out by Natalie Portman and Joe Jonas on alternate occasions. A few years later, following her relationship with Ted Lasso actor Jason Sudeikis, the actress-turned-director sold the Los Angeles spread at a loss to a music industry executive, who then sold it to a footwear mogul before Pharmavite CEO Jeff Boutelle and his wife Catherine bought it for just over $3 million. 13 years later, in a prestigious area in Los Feliz, this Spanish Colonial Revival-style mansion has once.

Originally designed by Ashton & Denney in the late 1920s and remodeled in the years since, the creamy stucco and red terracotta-roof structure is hidden away behind walls and gates, amid a hillside parcel spanning a little less than a quarter-acre of land. Inside, four bedrooms and an equal number of baths are spread across 3,284 square feet boasting a mix of tile and hardwood floors, vaulted wood-beam ceilings, stained-glass and leaded windows, decorative mosaic tile, and custom ironwork.

A secluded courtyard with a built-in barbecue and a fire pit conversation area flanks the rotunda entryway, which opens into a foyer holding a striking staircase that descends to a living room spotlighted by a fireplace and a Juliette balcony. From there, a sleekly updated kitchen is outfitted with open shelving set against a subway tile backsplash, an eat-in island, top-tier appliances, and a breakfast nook with banquette seating, while a handsome wood-paneled study is decked out with built-in bookshelves and a monogrammed fireplace. There’s also a screening room with the original bar and a primary suite flaunting a private balcony, a walk-in closet, and a spa-like bath holding dual vanities and a dark-tiled shower.

Regarding the garden-filled surroundings, they have winding trails, a spa with a waterfall, and outdoor areas for entertainment and relaxing that provide breathtaking views of downtown Los Angeles. The property is listed by Patricia Ruben and Alan Melkonyan of Sotheby’s International Realty-Los Feliz Brokerage. It also has an attached two-car garage.

Wilde has since moved on to other residential circumstances, having recently picked up a Barbara Bestor-designed compound in the Studio City area of L.A. for nearly $6 million. After the demise of her nearly decade-long relationship with Sudeikis in 2020, the couple’s jointly owned townhouse in Brooklyn went to Sudeikis and a renovated hacienda in L.A.’s Silver Lake neighborhood was sold for $4.2 million to an entertainment attorney and his wife.