Holley and Whitlock criticized the duo for perpetuating what they see as a significant deception, comparing it to a fast-food chain falsely advertising its products. They argue that the couple’s portrayal of their marriage has shaped public discourse, particularly in the wake of the infamous Oscar incident where Smith slapped comedian Chris Rock. According to the hosts, the fallout from this altercation has been compounded by the knowledge that the foundation of their discussions was built on a lie.